fake Christmas trees or fresh Christmas trees

This or That: Christmas Trees—Real or Fake?

One smells great, but the other comes predecorated—and both can pollute. Which should you allow in your house this year?

By Emily Main

Topics: this or that, Pesticides, holiday tips


When it comes to Christmas trees, think local and DIY to make the best choice.

Do you see a Christmas tree massacre or sustainable holiday decorating?

RODALE NEWS, EMMAUS, PA—If opting for a fresh Christmas tree over a fake one is a no-brainer in your mind, you're at odds with a majority of the public: Approximately 60 percent of Americans set up fake trees for the holidays, according to a 2004 poll by ABC News and The Washington Post. But—popularity aside—which is the healthier, more ecofriendly choice?

This: Fresh Christmas Trees

Pros: Few Christmas trees come from forests anymore. Virtually all of them are grown on plantations, and those plantations are located in all 50 states, making fresh Christmas trees easy to find locally. Buying real trees helps support small local farmers, and at the end of the holiday season, the trees can be mulched up and used to feed plants or find some other environmentally friendly purpose. In Louisiana, conservation groups use leftover Christmas trees to bolster coastal wetlands that have been eroded by hurricanes, and in Illinois, they are used to provide nesting habitats for herons.

Cons: Those real trees have real pest problems, and are usually grown with pesticides that are toxic to wildlife and, in some cases, to people. The most commonly used pesticide is Roundup, which is toxic to some birds and fish and was recently discovered to be toxic to human cells due to all the inert ingredients used. The Environmental Protection Agency has banned indoor use of some of the pesticides used on Christmas trees, such as chlorpyrifos and malathion, which damage human nervous systems.

Disagree with Real Cons I

Disagree with Real Cons

I would like to disagree with the Cons for buying a real tree. Though I am sure there are a whole bunch of tree sellers who utilize pesticides, there are MANY who don't.

My boyfriend owns a Christmas tree farm and he doesn't use any pesticide or fungicide. He uses Holly-tone organic fertilizer the year he plants trees and maybe once a year there after if the tree's need it. There is no need for pesticides at least up here in the north east.

Look for tree's that may have some lichen or moss growing on the trunk or some of the inner branches. Those trees were most likely grown without herbicides (and the lichen gives it character!).

Hey i heard that the cristmas

Hey i heard that the cristmas trees are cut and dogs are used to carry these trees. Snow dogs are really fit and work good in such things. Good help from the snow dogs that help in carrying the trees. Mario Games

we can use other interesting

we can use other interesting trees we made to instead the real trees, christmas holiday is a holiday we family all get together. cool gadgets

The web page is excellent!

The web page is excellent! You definitely know how to keep your target audience busy. Internet marketing hence thankful that I took the time to check out your blog, mainly because let me tell you. Thanks a lot. comparatif prix

For me I prefer to use the

For me I prefer to use the fake ones since it can last for long. Whereas the fresh is prone to insects and other animals. Anyway, if you need any plumbing services have a visit at Plumber Baltimore MD.

Welcome to buy Mulberry Bags

Welcome to buy Mulberry Bags UK,we offer such as mulberry handbags,mulberry wallets,and mulberry alexa bags Which is The Most Fashiponable With Free Shipping,No Sale Tax! Discount Mulberry outlet store are always here waiting for you!

80% OFF Sale cheap mulberry bags on our mulberry outlet,Buy Mulberry bags from our Mulberry factory shop outlet!We offer free shipping from mulberry online,we Mulberry Outlet have the AAA quality with the discount prices.

Mulberry factory shop offer mulberry bags online outlet.Annually mulberrys sale season offers 80% discount on all the genuine leather bags.Shop for your favorite Mulberry now for a price you can afford.

Luxury British label Mullberry Bags was founded in 1971 and has long been recognised for its highly crafted fine leather goods. The company's strength lies in its elegant Mullberry Handbags like the Bayswater and Alexa, which both became instant fashion classics. Mulberry factory shop online like the most British historic boutique which is more than a century old, after the brand become young, multi-pocket, multi-buckles, rivets and more so with aesthetic design and practicality, once again popular around the world.

Welcome http://www.mulberrymulberrys.org/

I prefer to use fake

I prefer to use fake Christmas tress or that plastic ones so we can reuse it again next Christmas. Anyway, have your heating and air-conditioning units installed or repaired? Visit us now HVAC Washington DC.

This Christmas is Trees are

This Christmas is Trees are real they are the one who use on AMC's TV series try to Watch The Walking Dead Season 2 Episode 8 and you will see that they are also using this kind of Christmas tree and the great of it is the organic touch that you can add in the blend of your very own decoration on how.

Your page is great! You sure

Your page is great! You sure do know how to keep your audience entertained. Im so glad that I took the time to look at this blog, because let me tell you. Thanks.

colored contact lenses for astigmatism

The trees are a crop - as

The trees are a crop - as rational and sustainable as any other, and provides the farmers with a living and then pleasure to those who prefer the real smell and look of an actual tree. The trees grown for this purpose are promptly replaced - they are not endangered like wild growth trees. Besides, if you have the space, and take care of it properly during the holiday, you can always take home a live one and plant it once the holiday has passed. If you have enough property the cut trees make great winter habitat for the birds and then in spring can be run through a chipper for mulch. This is not the kind of stupid cruelty like dying chicks colors and selling them for Easter - that IS sick. Farming Christmas trees is not.

Truly, nothing beats the real chistmas tree

Truly, nothing beats the real chistmas tree. They have the fresh scent that plastic trees cannot hope to have. Following the advice from the article, use organic trees, and after the holiday season, recycle the tree so that it becomes fertilizer for the next generation of trees.

Just paint it

Good grief - just paint one on the wall and hang decorations on it with push pins. Spray some fir tree oil around now and then. Or go outside and enjoy a living tree.

i would go for potted one

yes, the whole idea is to celebrate christmas without disturbing environment, it is among in one of the great Corporate Gift Ideas to recommend co-workers a potted tree, we have to better decrease the imports as well.

Go with a live tree!

As Sabine notes, why not go with a live tree that you can plant after the holiday (either right away or in the spring? I had friends in Massachusetts that did that every year. If you don't have a place for live tree, donate it to a park or school. Do a little homework first and find out what type of tree is native or will do best in your area (live and in the ground)!

Even with coastal rehabilitation and other worthy projects, it seems not cutting a tree is really the best.

Heidi

Christmas Trees

We've always done artificial. Some people are extra sensitive to the strong smell of natural pine in an enclosed area. When we "upgraded" our little apartment tree to a larger one for the house, I donated the old one to Goodwill. The employees there were very appreciative of it. They had a sign-up list for customers wanting to purchase used artificial trees! Don't throw out your old artificial trees unless they are truly ready to fall apart. Donate them to Goodwill, Salvation Army, Amvets, or any other second-hand charity store. There is a market for them and by allowing someone else the chance to re-use the tree, that tree will most likely be used for at least 20 years, if not longer. And even falling apart artificial trees can be re-purposed as decorations. Use the good branches to make evergreen swags, garlands, wreaths, and the like, and truly deck the halls!

x-mas trees

Why not a living tree, so that after x-mas it can be planted back into the ground. My family and I do this every year and feel good about giving back to the Earth after the holidays. T'is the season for giving! Also, if you do not have room outdoors to replant your tree, why not check with your local parks department. Maybe they would love to replant it for you at one of the local parks.

Real Christmas Trees all the way!!!

We grow Choose and Cut Christmas Trees in MN and use NO pesticides or herbicides on them at all. I would much rather have a real tree in my house than one of those Chinese made lead-laden fakes! Additionally, when a tree is cut, a new one is planted. We put more acreage in trees this year so planted another 2000 trees in addition to the spots we were filling in. It takes 8-10 years for a tree to become a Christmas tree, and in that time it makes a great home for birds and other wildlife. When the trees get too big to be Christmas trees, they become a great hideout for pheasants and deer. Real trees are a win-win!!!

FAKE!

OMIGOD cutting down and killing a tree annually and then dumping it? That's environmentally friendly?? FOR REAL? C'mon now.. most people I know have had their fake trees way longer than 20 years.

People are insane! Really something wrong with you if you think something that lasts you your lifetime is not as environmentally friendly as killing a tree annually and then dumping it, not to mention the fires.

Our fake tree is 35 yrs. old & guilt-free

We bought an artificial tree back in the mid-70's, completely assembled and bedecked with lights and ornaments, for a bargain price. We drove home with it carefully handheld upright in the bed of our pickup by a family friend. Over the years, it has become a part of our family traditions, the original lights and some of the ornaments replaced, but the tree itself dependably ready for its yearly resurrection from the storage boxes which house it out of season in its disassembled state. There were times during those three-plus decades that we lived in a very small single-wide trailer with a wood-burning stove, without room to safely erect a full-size Christmas tree. My clever dear husband solved the problem by using just some of the branches and creating an espalier evergreen, attaching them in a pyramidal shape flat to the wall. With strategically placed small lights and ornaments chosen for their thin profile, we were able to enjoy our tree just as much as in other years when we possessed more square feet to spread out. After all this time and the many years of use and re-use, we feel guilt-free in our choice of an artificial tree.

Roundup Toxic Inert Ingredients

Greetings, Peter -

A French TV documentary recently broadcast the findings from several studies to the effect that the main poison in RoundUp, glyphosate, has its effects greatly amplified by one of the inert surfactants also found in RoundUp, and the two in combination are far more toxic than either is alone.

Google "Glyphosate toxic inert" for a whole host of articles, many of which refer to the French documentary.

The inert ingredient in this case has been shown to be toxic to human cells all by itself, including placental and embryonic cells, and combined with glyphosate can be deadly.

Inert does not mean nontoxic.

Real Christmas Trees

About ten years ago I bought a multi-trunked potted Norfolk Island pine and brought it home as our Christmas tree. I re-potted it into a large clay pot, set it into a large saucer on top of a cedar chest, and my then-husband anchored the top of the tree to our track lights with strong cord, to prevent our cats from inadvertently knocking it over. We decorated both tree and pot, and even though the tree was inside for nearly a month, we never had a problem as it was kept properly watered.

This tree was our Christmas tree for six or eight years, which lived happily outside the rest of the year, on the back porch of our condo. When I moved into a home without cathedral ceilings, the tree was too tall for me to use inside, and we planted it in the front yard. Last year I bought another multi-trunked Norfolk Island pine, and this will be our second year using it as our Christmas tree.

I like the idea of using a living tree which will be a part of our holidays for many years to come. These trees do beautifully in this part of Florida, they look beautiful once decorated, and they are not overly stressed during their time inside the house, unlike most more traditional Christmas tree species. In addition, they will live happily in a large pot for many, many years.

And, any time we want that Christmas tree smell, we light some pinon or spruce incense. ;-)

Toxic Chrismas Trees

How can you make the statement that Roundup is toxic because of the INERT ingredients? Toxic it may be, but not because it is inert!

Christmas Trees

I have successfully planted living evergreens to my yard in winter by doing a few things ahead of time. I dig the hole and fill it with straw or leaves, and keep the backfill on a tarp close by. When using a live tree it should be kept in the house for a limited amount of time. Spraying it with a dessicant will help it to hold moisture in. I have always decorated the tree on Christmas Eve - fun family project - and taken it down the day after Christmas. In a way that makes the tree more special because it isn't around for very long. Then we take the tree out to the predug hole. Plant, backfill, and be sure to mulch heavily with leaves, wood chips or whatever you are mulching with. This is a blanket for the roots. If you live where deer are plentiful be sure to protect the tree from the nibbling critters. Putting out a new tree in winter is the same as opening the all you can eat salad bar. Merry Christmas to All.....

Real or fake trees - minimize environmental impact

The article does not mention that you can get a small tree with roots. Which you can have in the house for up to one week, then keep outside (frost free) and well watered and lit and re-plant in spring. With some care these little guys are just wonderful for a small family and will make it through the season without drying out.
We have a couple of them in containers which also look good at your front door.

No matter what choice, although I prefer real trees, I would always recommend to use Christmas as a time to gather. A big family feast with one tree avoids cutting too many trees for each satellite family.

Season's Greetings

Sabine

free daily newsletter

Sign up for the FREE daily newsletter and receive a FREE gift, 25 Secrets for Healthy Living on a Healthy Planet ($4.95 value).

Email:

Rodale.com on Facebook

follow @RodaleNews

Get the latest news and useful tips about your health, food, and the environment!


Tweet Here
Advertisement
Rodale Home Remedies Finder

Find (or share!) a solution for all your aches & pains. Thousands of tried and true safe remedies!