spreading flu

This or That: Kill Flu Germs with Bleach or Disinfectant?

There are lots of ways to wipe out swine-flu microbes, but some of them could be unhealthy for your home.

By Emily Main

Topics: cleaning products, homemade cleaners


Pick the disinfectant that's both effective and won't have long-term health or environmental effects.

Wipe out swine flu germs, without unhealthy aftereffects.

RODALE NEWS, EMMAUS, PA—If you have a family member or roommate who's succumbed to the H1N1 virus, inadvertently spreading flu germs could be as easy as touching a sink faucet. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends disinfecting all hard surfaces to avoid spreading flu microbes around your house—either swine flu, which is circulating now, or the ordinary seasonal variety, which we can look forward to later this winter. But while many household disinfectants such as chlorine bleach, and ammonia-based products like Lysol, are registered by the Environmental Protection Agency to kill the flu virus, they also contain harsh chemicals that may cause respiratory damage, long-term hormone disruption, and harm to the environment. On the other hand, natural disinfectants like vinegar and hydrogen peroxide, which have been tested and found to kill certain foodborne illnesses, germs, and other microbes, don't have an established track record against the flu virus. So how should you keep from spreading flu around your home without putting your long-term health at risk?

This: Chlorine Bleach

Pros: Chlorine bleach is effective at killing viruses, including strains of the flu, as well as bacteria, because it actually penetrates the germs' outer membranes to kill them completely. In fact, a 2007 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine found that chlorine was a much more effective disinfectant than standard antibacterial products, which are ineffective against viruses. Because you mix it with water, a little bit can go a long way.

Cons: In addition to potentially singeing your respiratory tract and irritating your skin, chlorine is a common cause of poisonings in children under 6 years old. Production of chlorine is also one of the leading emitters of mercury into the environment, and its production releases cancer-causing dioxin, which accumulates in cow's milk and other animal fats.

Disinfectants are different

Disinfectants are different from other antimicrobial agents such as antibiotics, which destroy microorganisms within the body, and antiseptics, which destroy microorganisms on living tissue. -Mario Romano

Mixing Chlorine & Vinegar

You should not mix the two because it causes a chemical reaction that releases some Chlorine gas.

Why not vinegar?

Probably because it doesn't kill flu virus!

Disinfection

We agree that applying a solution of bleach and water to hard surfaces is a great way to disinfect hard surfaces. Just add 1/4 cup of bleach to 1 gallon of water to mix up a germ-busting surface disinfectant.

To say that chlorine production is a leading emitter of mercury and dioxin into the environment is simply not true. Bleach is made by chemically reacting chlorine and lye (sodium hydroxide). No dioxin is produced during the manufacture of bleach. And mercury is used in only four U.S. facilities in to help produce chlorine. The global chlorine industry is a very small source of mercury emissions – accounting for less than one-tenth of one percent of total global emissions of mercury from all natural and man-made sources.

Scott Jensen, American Chemistry Council

disinfectant

Why not vinegar?

free daily newsletter

Sign up for the FREE daily newsletter and receive a FREE gift, 25 Secrets for Healthy Living on a Healthy Planet ($4.95 value).

Email:

Rodale.com on Facebook

follow @RodaleNews

Get the latest news and useful tips about your health, food, and the environment!


Tweet Here
Advertisement
Rodale Home Remedies Finder

Find (or share!) a solution for all your aches & pains. Thousands of tried and true safe remedies!